Cart Drawer vs Popup Cart: Which Converts Better?

Cart drawers and popup carts are two common checkout elements Shopify stores use to increase average order value. Both aim to reduce abandonment and checkout friction, but their design differences impact user behavior.

What Is a Cart Drawer?

A cart drawer is a sliding panel that appears from the side of a webpage when customers add items to their cart. 

Cart drawers display cart contents without redirecting users. For this, they keep shoppers on the same screen, reduce distractions and maintain focus on the purchase journey. 

For Shopify stores, this feature is particularly effective because it allows merchants to display upsells, free shipping progress bars, and payment installments without redirecting users.

What Is a Popup Cart?

A popup cart is a modal window that overlays the current page after an item is added to the cart. 

In contrast to cart drawer, a popup cart overlays the current page as a modal window and often requires immediate action. 

Popup carts are designed for immediate action: it shows a condensed summary of the cart while allowing quick access to checkout. For time-sensitive promotions or stores with straightforward product lines, popups can create urgency without overwhelming shoppers.

Which Design Converts Better?

Cart Drawers: The Low-Friction Advantage

Cart drawers slide in from the side of the screen without taking customers away from the product page. This keeps the shopping experience smooth and helps people continue browsing. Since there’s no page reload, it feels faster and less disruptive. Shoppers can easily review what’s in their cart while staying focused on buying. This low-friction flow often leads to fewer drop-offs and more completed checkouts.

Popup Carts: Urgency and Upsell Opportunities

Popup carts appear in the center of the screen right after a product is added. This design grabs attention and creates a sense of urgency to finish the purchase. It’s also a great place to suggest upsells like “complete the look” or “buy more, save more.” Because the popup interrupts the flow, it’s best used when you want the customer to take immediate action. It works especially well during sales or with time-limited offers.

Looking to display cart drawer in your Shopify store? Install Cartly in your Shopify store and start free.

Cart Drawer vs Popup Cart: Which one should you use in your Shopify store?

The choice between cart drawer vs popup cart should align with your specific business model, customer behavior patterns, and conversion optimization goals. Stores with high average order values and complex product catalogs often benefit from cart drawers because they support extended browsing sessions without creating friction.

Fashion retailers, electronics stores, and businesses selling complementary products typically see better results with cart drawers. These merchants rely on customers discovering additional items during their shopping journey, and the non-intrusive nature of drawer interfaces supports this exploration behavior while maintaining cart visibility.

Popup carts perform well in scenarios where immediate conversion is the primary goal. Single-product stores, limited-time offers, and high-impulse purchase categories often achieve better results with the focused attention that popup interfaces provide. The modal design creates urgency and eliminates decision paralysis by removing competing visual elements.

Consider your mobile traffic patterns when making this decision. Cart drawers generally provide superior mobile experiences because they don't require full-screen real estate and allow for easier one-handed navigation..

Choose Cart Drawers If…

• Your store prioritizes browsing (e.g., fashion or home decor)

• You offer multi-step discounts or bundling

• You want to keep customers on the product page while they shop

• Your store focuses on browsing multiple items or bundles

• You aim for a frictionless, uninterrupted shopping experience

Example: Let’s say you run a Shopify store selling home décor. A customer clicks on a cushion, adds it to their cart, and the cart drawer slides in from the right. They can quickly check the item, close the drawer, and keep browsing matching curtains or rugs without being pulled away from the page. This flow helps keep their focus and encourages adding more to the cart.

Choose Popup Carts If…

• You run time-sensitive promotions and want to create urgency or highlight limited-time offers

• Your products have natural cross-sell pairs (e.g., phone cases and chargers)

• Checkout pages have high abandonment rates

• Your store relies on impulse purchases or small ticket items.

• You plan to use it for upsells or cross-sells right after add-to-cart.

Example: Imagine you sell phone accessories, and a shopper adds a phone case to their cart. A popup cart appears immediately with a message: “Add a screen protector now and get 10% off!” The popup grabs their attention and encourages a quick upsell. It also reminds them to complete their purchase without delay, which is great for time-sensitive promotions.

Final Verdict: It Depends on Your Customers

There’s no universal winner. Analyze your Shopify analytics: if mobile users abandon carts after viewing shipping costs, prioritize cart drawers with real-time progress bars. If desktop users linger on checkout pages, test popup carts with installment offers.

This article was created with assistance from vevy.ai and proofread, fact-checked, and validated by its author.